Graded Goofs!
Slabbers' scams or graders' goofs? Cards in slabs should have 100% accurate labels but it's not always so, and graders have made some of the WORST mistakes in cards history! Yet people still pay them to make mistakes. So, to be clear: cards from me are sold as seen. I do not accept what coin or USbaseball card graders tell me about European cards which they often have little or no experience of. If you use graders, fine, it's your choice but don't come back to me and say it graded lower... or they did not know... or they said it was.. They do not know a fraction of what European and South American experts know! I have known graders say Nannina cards are "altered" (well, they are strip cards!) and Stella cards are trimmed (they were hand guillotined!) and so on... it's like taking your priceless yesteryear Bentley to a garage for a service and having the trendy young sales assistant tell you he can't fit an EV cobalt battery into it! So, it's worthless. Not!
Graders are to cards what Accountants are to money; what Financial Advisers are to people who buy shares, treasuries, gilts, bonds and other financial instruments, but only accountants and advisers can do jail time for giving wrongful info. Maybe that will soon change. The FBI are presently looking at graders and slabbers due to some well documented recent scams.
Wrongly graded cards, such as slabbed forgeries (marking fakes as genuine); altered cards (grading trimmed cards as untrimmed: trimming makes cards look newer, neater and more valuable); wrongly dated cards (earlier dates give inflated values to many cards); and mis-identified makes, marques and other wrongly-called collections may lead collectors into murky waters and may even lead to heavy financial losses!
In recent times I have seen my own postings removed from social media and sports cards forums. My posts on bum-graded cards and dodgy-dated slabs have upset some people. They have gathered in force to remove (censor) the information I had made public. American-based sports card forums have removed most of what you will find below. I am showing them all here, again, due to the removal of the images elsewhere.
Though I do hate plastic slabs - poisonous material we need less of in the world, not more - I have nothing against graders, as long as they do their jobs well. They may make millions out of collectors but if collectors are happy to pay hard-earned money for plastic slabs that's the collectors' lookout and the graders' good fortune. I only have issues with wrongly graded cards - that's all.
Yet, slabbing of rare stamps does not happen. Slabbing of rare postcards? No. Rare coins? Not often. So, rare cards do not need to be slabbed either but if they are slabbed they need the correct grade and honest information. The value is in the card but the value is massively influenced by what a slabber writes on a slab's label: a label that's often written by someone who knows less than you do!
If you do get your cards slabbed at least let's keep the slabbers attentive and honest. If they know that they must do a top-notch job - or else fines and even prison may await - I am certain they will try harder. That's why this gallery is here. It's a reminder. It lets you learn from the past ... from such cons as the Raven MUFC Fergie's Fledgling cards so wrongly graded as 1995 (and sold for £1000's) even though the cards were actually produced after 2000
-
1934 ROOKIE LIE$ Stanley Matthews graders lie Hill Popular Footballers 1934 is actually later 1935
£0.00 -
1967 Charles Buchan World Stars Pele Sprake pair versus an uncut sheet
£0.00 -
Baines golf ball badly dated slab Cambridge golf club 1921 but graded as 1897!
£0.00 -
Fake! Someone graded a fake! Not a real ILSA card but slabbed all the same
£0.00 -
Grader's goof! Eusebio rookie summer scene from EC62 released in fall 62 slabbed as 1961!
£0.00 -
graders goof Schutt 1960 as 1961 Did as pele and the similar 1961 Heinerle
£0.00 -
L: colour 1960 Heinerle often misgraded as 1958 or 1959; and R: 1958 Bremer Pelé sold for £41,000
£0.00 -
Not 1995! Actually 2000-2001. Raven Beckham Fergie's Fledglings card made in Spain or so it seems!
£0.00 -
Pele 1966 German sticker slabbed and graded as 1961 even though the sticker states "1966"!
£0.00